[民事-確認本票債權不存在-勝訴]-勝訴案例精選81

梁雨安 律師
發表時間:2022/05/31 21:27 320 次瀏覽

👉本件僅協助撰狀

👉本票債權不存在關於原因關係舉證責任之分配,實務見解相當混亂,故案件的重點,會在於檢索並援引有利的最高法院見解

一、📜案例事實📜

上訴人主張被上訴人係以強暴脅迫之方式逼其簽下本票,且該本票債權之原因關係債權亦不存在,訴請確認該本票債權不存在,經原審判決上訴人敗訴,上訴人不服,提起上訴

二、💪本律師協助被上訴人答辯如下 💪

(一)強暴脅迫之舉證部分,依最高法院21年上字第2010號判例,票據債務人主張執票人取得票據出於惡意或詐欺、脅迫時,應由該債務人負舉證之責,於本案,原告就其主張被告強暴脅迫其簽立本票乙事,於另案提出之刑事恐嚇取財部分,已遭地檢署為不起訴處分,高檢署再議駁回處分,自應認其主張並非可採。

(二)原因關係舉證部分,現行實務上,如原告請求確認票據債權不存在時時,被告僅須就該票據之真實,即票據是否為原告作成之事實負證明之責,原告仍須就票據原因關係不存在乙事,負舉證責任,原告既無法證明該本票之原因關係不存在,自應為原告敗訴之認定。

三、🏆️案件結果🏆️

案經新竹地方法院採認本律師上開主張,為被上訴人勝訴之判決(上訴駁回)

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

律師簡介及聯絡資訊

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

勝訴案例精選1-[民事-海砂屋減少價金案-逆轉勝]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/169/1

勝訴案例精選2-[民事-遺產爭訟案-勝訴]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/172/2

勝訴案例精選3-[民事-確認優先承購權存在案-勝訴]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/173/3

勝訴案例精選4-[刑事-偽造文書案-不起訴]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/174/4

勝訴案例精選5-[民事-損害賠償案-勝訴]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/175/5

勝訴案例精選6-[刑事-貪污案-不起訴]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/176/6

勝訴案例精選7-[刑事-妨害名譽案-不起訴]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/178

勝訴案例精選8-[民事-遷讓房屋案-勝訴]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/179

勝訴案例精選9-[民事-當選無效案-逆轉勝]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/180

勝訴案例精選10-[刑事-偽造文書案-和解撤告]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/181/10

勝訴案例精選11-[刑事-未成年性交案-不起訴]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/182/11

勝訴案例精選12-[民事-請求給付仲介報酬-勝訴]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/183/12

勝訴案例精選13-[刑事-槍砲彈藥刀械管制條例-獲判緩刑]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/184

勝訴案例精選14-[刑事-幫助詐欺案-不起訴]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/189

勝訴案例精選15-[民事-給付工程款-勝訴]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/191/15

勝訴案例精選16-[刑事-過失傷害-調解成立]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/197

勝訴案例精選17-[刑事-銀行法-勝訴]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/198

勝訴案例精選18-[民事-共有物分割-勝訴]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/199

勝訴案例精選19-[民事-共有物分割-勝訴]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/200

勝訴案例精選20-[民事-確認通行權存在-勝訴]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/202

勝訴案例精選21-[民事-遷讓房屋-勝訴]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/203/21

勝訴案例精選22-[民事-漏水減少價金-勝訴]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/204

勝訴案例精選23-[民事-確認本票債權不存在勝訴]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/205/23

勝訴案例精選24-[刑事-加重強盜案-勝訴]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/206

勝訴案例精選25-[刑事-妨害名譽案-逆轉勝]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/207/25

勝訴案例精選26-[刑事-販毒案-獲判緩刑]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/208

勝訴案例精選27-[刑事-妨害投票案-六個被告均無罪]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/215

勝訴案例精選28-[民事-遷讓房屋案-勝訴]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/218

勝訴案例精選29-[刑事-藥事法案-獲判緩刑]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/219

勝訴案例精選30-[民事-遺產案-勝訴]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/220

勝訴案例精選31-[刑事-妨害自由案-不起訴]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/221

勝訴案例精選32-[民事-請求給付租金案-全勝]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/222

勝訴案例精選33-[民事-監護宣告案-勝訴]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/223

勝訴案例精選34-[民事-確認本票債權不存在案勝訴

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/224

勝訴案例精選35-[民事-返還借款案-全勝]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/225

勝訴案例精選36-[刑事-人頭帳戶詐欺案-不起訴]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/226

勝訴案例精選37-[刑事-背信案-不起訴]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/227

勝訴案例精選38-[刑事-業務侵占案-不起訴

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/228

勝訴案例精選39-[刑事-背信案-不起訴]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/230

勝訴案例精選40-[刑事-商業會計法案-不起訴

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/231/40

勝訴案例精選41-[刑事-妨害自由案-再議駁回]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/232

勝訴案例精選42-[刑事-背信案-不起訴]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/233

勝訴案例精選43-[刑事-販毒案-刑法59條減刑]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/245/59-43

勝訴案例精選44-[民事-拆屋還地-勝訴]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/246/44

勝訴案例精選45-[民事-個資法損害賠償-判賠]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/247/45

勝訴案例精選46-[刑事-家暴殺人-撤銷發回]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/249

勝訴案例精選47-[刑事-加重詐欺-撤銷發回]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/250/47

勝訴案例精選48-[民事-訴訟參加-駁回]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/251/48

勝訴案例精選49-[刑事-廢棄物清理法-無罪]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/254/49

勝訴案例精選50-[刑事-偽造文書-起訴]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/264/50

勝訴案例精選51-[刑事-妨害名譽-不起訴]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/273/51

勝訴案例精選52-[刑事-強制性交-不起訴]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/275/52

勝訴案例精選53-[刑事-銀行法-無罪]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/276/53

勝訴案例精選54-[刑事-廢清法-緩刑]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/282/54

勝訴案例精選55-[家事-確認親子關係存在-勝訴]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/284

勝訴案例精選56-[家事-離婚-調解成立]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/285/56

勝訴案例精選57-[家事離婚、民事借名登記-調解成立]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/286/57

勝訴案例精選58-[刑事-證劵交易法-緩刑]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/288

勝訴案例精選59-[民事-確認本票債權不存在-勝訴]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/289/59

勝訴案例精選60-[刑事-竊盜-不起訴]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/293/60

勝訴案例精選61-[民事-抗告-勝訴]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/294/61

勝訴案例精選62 -[民事-給付委任報酬-勝訴近千萬]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/295/62

勝訴案例精選63-[刑事-侵占、背信、恐嚇-不起訴]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/297/63

勝訴案例精選64-[刑事-過失傷害-勝訴]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/298/64

勝訴案例精選65-[刑事-人頭帳戶詐欺案-不起訴]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/303/65

勝訴案例精選66-[刑事-詐欺案-再議發回續查]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/311/66

勝訴案例精選67-[民事-損害賠償-勝訴]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/312/67

勝訴案例精選68-[民事-分割共有物-勝訴]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/313/68

勝訴案例精選69-[刑事-加重詐欺-勝訴]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/326

勝訴案例精選70-[民事-損害賠償-勝訴]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/327/70

勝訴案例精選71-[刑事-背信-勝訴]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/352/71

勝訴案例精選72-[刑事-詐欺-勝訴]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/361/72

勝訴案例精選73-[智財-專利-勝訴]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/364

勝訴案例精選74-[刑事-詐欺-勝訴]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/365/74

勝訴案例精選75-[民事-凶宅減少價金-勝訴]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/366/75

勝訴案例精選76-[智財-商標-核駁先行]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/367/76

勝訴案例精選77-[刑事-人頭帳戶詐欺案-不起訴]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/368

勝訴案例精選78-[智財-專利-勝訴]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/369/78

勝訴案例精選79-[刑事-恐嚇取財-再議發回]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/370

勝訴案例精選80-[智財-商標廢止-廢止處分]

https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/371/80

梁雨安 律師

  • 進豐聯合法律事務所
  • 桃園市桃園區大興西路一段262號5樓