(一)刑事案件。
(三)撤銷緩刑案件,難度雖沒到再審、交付審判、非常上訴之絕望等級,但成功的機率還是很低,10件中有1件成功翻盤就很厲害了。
(四)本件是代撰抗告理由狀。
(五)本件其實還有公示送達和監所送達的問題,攸關本件抗告是否逾期,但此部分因法院認為抗告合法,故裁定未再多做論述。
檢察官以受刑人未履行緩刑條件為由,聲請法院撤銷緩刑,經原審法院認定被告確實未履行緩刑條件,情節重大,進而撤銷受刑人之緩刑,受刑人不服該裁定,依法提出抗告
(一)違反第74條第2項第l款至第8款所定負擔「情節重大」者,當從受刑人自始是否真心願意接受緩刑所附之負擔,或於緩刑期間中是否顯有履行負擔之可能而隱匿或處分其財產、故意不履行、無正當事由拒絕履行或顯有逃匿之虞等情事而言,考量受刑人未履行條件情形,與被害人所受損害間,依比例原則綜合衡酌原宣告之緩刑是否難收其預期之效果,而確有執行刑罰之必要,資以決定該緩刑宣告是否應予撤銷,非謂受刑人一不履行即當然應撤銷緩刑。
(二)受刑人雖未依原確定判決諭知之緩刑條件按時給付,但仍有與被害人聯繫還款事宜,且仍繼續給付款項予被害人,此與原審認定受刑人未再給付任何款項有異。受刑人雖有未按原確定判決諭知之給付方式履行賠償之違反負擔情事,然是否已該當刑法第75條之1第1項第4款所定「情節重大」之情狀,容非無疑。原審未予審究詳查,逕認受刑人違反緩刑宣告所定負擔情節重大,稍嫌速斷
案經台灣高等法院採認本律師上開主張,撤銷原審裁定,發回原審法院另為適法之決定。
---------------------------
專業、用心、親力親為
律師簡介及聯絡資訊
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315
---------------------------
勝訴案例精選1-[民事-海砂屋減少價金案-逆轉勝]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/169/1
勝訴案例精選2-[民事-遺產爭訟案-勝訴]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/172/2
勝訴案例精選3-[民事-確認優先承購權存在案-勝訴]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/173/3
勝訴案例精選4-[刑事-偽造文書案-不起訴]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/174/4
勝訴案例精選5-[民事-損害賠償案-勝訴]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/175/5
勝訴案例精選6-[刑事-貪污案-不起訴]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/176/6
勝訴案例精選7-[刑事-妨害名譽案-不起訴]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/178
勝訴案例精選8-[民事-遷讓房屋案-勝訴]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/179
勝訴案例精選9-[民事-當選無效案-逆轉勝]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/180
勝訴案例精選10-[刑事-偽造文書案-和解撤告]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/181/10
勝訴案例精選11-[刑事-未成年性交案-不起訴]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/182/11
勝訴案例精選12-[民事-請求給付仲介報酬-勝訴]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/183/12
勝訴案例精選13-[刑事-槍砲彈藥刀械管制條例-獲判緩刑]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/184
勝訴案例精選14-[刑事-幫助詐欺案-不起訴]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/189
勝訴案例精選15-[民事-給付工程款-勝訴]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/191/15
勝訴案例精選16-[刑事-過失傷害-調解成立]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/197
勝訴案例精選17-[刑事-銀行法-勝訴]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/198
勝訴案例精選18-[民事-共有物分割-勝訴]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/199
勝訴案例精選19-[民事-共有物分割-勝訴]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/200
勝訴案例精選20-[民事-確認通行權存在-勝訴]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/202
勝訴案例精選21-[民事-遷讓房屋-勝訴]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/203/21
勝訴案例精選22-[民事-漏水減少價金-勝訴]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/204
勝訴案例精選23-[民事-確認本票債權不存在勝訴]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/205/23
勝訴案例精選24-[刑事-加重強盜案-勝訴]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/206
勝訴案例精選25-[刑事-妨害名譽案-逆轉勝]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/207/25
勝訴案例精選26-[刑事-販毒案-獲判緩刑]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/208
勝訴案例精選27-[刑事-妨害投票案-六個被告均無罪]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/215
勝訴案例精選28-[民事-遷讓房屋案-勝訴]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/218
勝訴案例精選29-[刑事-藥事法案-獲判緩刑]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/219
勝訴案例精選30-[民事-遺產案-勝訴]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/220
勝訴案例精選31-[刑事-妨害自由案-不起訴]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/221
勝訴案例精選32-[民事-請求給付租金案-全勝]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/222
勝訴案例精選33-[民事-監護宣告案-勝訴]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/223
勝訴案例精選34-[民事-確認本票債權不存在案勝訴
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/224
勝訴案例精選35-[民事-返還借款案-全勝]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/225
勝訴案例精選36-[刑事-人頭帳戶詐欺案-不起訴]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/226
勝訴案例精選37-[刑事-背信案-不起訴]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/227
勝訴案例精選38-[刑事-業務侵占案-不起訴
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/228
勝訴案例精選39-[刑事-背信案-不起訴]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/230
勝訴案例精選40-[刑事-商業會計法案-不起訴
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/231/40
勝訴案例精選41-[刑事-妨害自由案-再議駁回]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/232
勝訴案例精選42-[刑事-背信案-不起訴]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/233
勝訴案例精選43-[刑事-販毒案-刑法59條減刑]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/245/59-43
勝訴案例精選44-[民事-拆屋還地-勝訴]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/246/44
勝訴案例精選45-[民事-個資法損害賠償-判賠]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/247/45
勝訴案例精選46-[刑事-家暴殺人-撤銷發回]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/249
勝訴案例精選47-[刑事-加重詐欺-撤銷發回]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/250/47
勝訴案例精選48-[民事-訴訟參加-駁回]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/251/48
勝訴案例精選49-[刑事-廢棄物清理法-無罪]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/254/49
勝訴案例精選50-[刑事-偽造文書-起訴]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/264/50
勝訴案例精選51-[刑事-妨害名譽-不起訴]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/273/51
勝訴案例精選52-[刑事-強制性交-不起訴]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/275/52
勝訴案例精選53-[刑事-銀行法-無罪]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/276/53
勝訴案例精選54-[刑事-廢清法-緩刑]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/282/54
勝訴案例精選55-[家事-確認親子關係存在-勝訴]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/284
勝訴案例精選56-[家事-離婚-調解成立]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/285/56
勝訴案例精選57-[家事離婚、民事借名登記-調解成立]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/286/57
勝訴案例精選58-[刑事-證劵交易法-緩刑]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/288
勝訴案例精選59-[民事-確認本票債權不存在-勝訴]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/289/59
勝訴案例精選60-[刑事-竊盜-不起訴]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/293/60
勝訴案例精選61-[民事-抗告-勝訴]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/294/61
勝訴案例精選62 -[民事-給付委任報酬-勝訴近千萬]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/295/62
勝訴案例精選63-[刑事-侵占、背信、恐嚇-不起訴]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/297/63
勝訴案例精選64-[刑事-過失傷害-勝訴]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/298/64
勝訴案例精選65-[刑事-人頭帳戶詐欺案-不起訴]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/303/65
勝訴案例精選66-[刑事-詐欺案-再議發回續查]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/311/66
勝訴案例精選67-[民事-損害賠償-勝訴]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/312/67
勝訴案例精選68-[民事-分割共有物-勝訴]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/313/68
勝訴案例精選69-[刑事-加重詐欺-勝訴]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/326
勝訴案例精選70-[民事-損害賠償-勝訴]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/327/70
勝訴案例精選71-[刑事-背信-勝訴]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/352/71
勝訴案例精選72-[刑事-詐欺-勝訴]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/361/72
勝訴案例精選73-[智財-專利-勝訴]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/364
勝訴案例精選74-[刑事-詐欺-勝訴]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/365/74
勝訴案例精選75-[民事-凶宅減少價金-勝訴]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/366/75
勝訴案例精選76-[智財-商標-核駁先行]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/367/76
勝訴案例精選77-[刑事-人頭帳戶詐欺案-不起訴]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/368
勝訴案例精選78-[智財-專利-勝訴]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/369/78
勝訴案例精選79-[刑事-恐嚇取財-再議發回]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/370
勝訴案例精選80-[智財-商標廢止-廢止處分]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/371/80
勝訴案例精選81-[民事-確認本票債權不存在-勝訴]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/375/81
勝訴案例精選82-[民事-排除侵害-勝訴]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/380/82
勝訴案例精選83-[民事-返還不當得利-勝訴]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/409/83
勝訴案例精選84 -[刑事-侵占-不起訴]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/421/84
勝訴案例精選85-[刑事-毒品-緩刑]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/422/85
勝訴案例精選86-[刑事-詐欺-起訴]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/423/86
勝訴案例精選87-[刑事-販賣第二級毒品-無罪]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/425/87
勝訴案例精選88-[刑事-偽證-不起訴]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/426/88
勝訴案例精選89-[民事-請求給付承攬報酬-勝訴]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/428/89
勝訴案例精選90-[刑事-人頭帳戶詐欺案-不起訴]
https://www.lawchain.tw/lawyer/315/posts/430/90
勝訴案例精選91-[民事-返還借款案-勝訴]